Skip to content
MSM

Crafty Controller vs Minecraft Server Manager

Both are free, self-hosted panels made for Minecraft. Crafty runs each server as a process on the host, written in Python. Minecraft Server Manager runs each server in its own Docker container and builds modpacks, mod search and crash tools into the panel.

  • Docker
  • Linux
  • Windows
  • macOS
  • arm64

Containers Instead of Host Processes

In Minecraft Server Manager every server is its own Docker container on the well-known itzg Minecraft image, with its own memory and CPU limits and a disk quota the panel enforces. One server cannot eat the machine's memory or fill its disk, and rebuilding a server never touches the others. The trade is that Docker has to be installed on the host.

  • Memory, CPU and disk limits per server.
  • Graceful RCON stop before the container stops, and crash detection with backoff.
  • Java is picked per server by the image, so mixed Minecraft versions just work.
  • Docker
  • amd64
  • arm64
A server's overview with resource meters and quick actions.

Where Minecraft Server Manager Is Stronger

The wizard installs modpacks and mods for you and keeps them pinned, so a restart never silently upgrades a pack.

  • Install CurseForge, Modrinth, FTB and GT New Horizons packs from the wizard.
  • Import a Modrinth .mrpack, a CurseForge export or your own zip of jars, with every jar identified.
  • Search five registries at once, filtered to the server's loader and version.
  • Upgrades take a backup first and roll back in one click.
  • One-click BlueMap live map and mclo.gs crash sharing.
  • Portable blueprints: export a server's recipe and get the same server anywhere.
  • CurseForge packs
  • Modrinth packs
  • FTB
  • GT New Horizons
  • .mrpack
  • CurseForge export

When Crafty Controller Is the Better Pick

Crafty is mature, actively maintained, and runs in more places without Docker.

  • You want to run servers without installing Docker, for example directly on Windows, macOS or a Raspberry Pi.
  • You run Bedrock Dedicated Server itself, not only Java with Geyser.
  • You want passkey sign-in.

Side by Side

Minecraft Server ManagerCrafty Controller
Price and licenceFree, MIT.Free, GPL-3.0.
Written inNode.js 24.Python 3.10 to 3.12.
Game servers run asResource-capped Docker containers.Processes on the host. The panel itself can also run in Docker.
DockerRequired on the host.Optional.
Host systemsLinux, Windows and macOS. The image is built for amd64 and arm64.Linux, Windows, macOS and Raspberry Pi OS, plus Docker, UnRAID and CasaOS guides. Its image covers amd64 and arm64.
EditionsJava Edition. Bedrock players can join through Geyser.Java Edition from 1.8 to the latest, and Bedrock.
ModpacksCurseForge, Modrinth, FTB and GT New Horizons packs from the wizard, pinned to an exact version.Its FAQ describes importing a pack as a zip, or Modrinth packs through mrpack-install.
Backups, schedules, roles, 2FAYes: retention per server, cron schedules, three roles with per-server permissions, TOTP.Yes: a backup manager, a task scheduler, user roles, and TOTP plus passkeys.

Facts checked October 2026 against each project's own documentation.

Crafty Controller Questions

Can I move my Crafty server into Minecraft Server Manager?
Yes. Create a server with the same type and Minecraft version, then upload the world as a zip on the Worlds page and install it to that server. For a modded server, import your pack or a zip of the mod jars when you create it.
Does Minecraft Server Manager run on a Raspberry Pi?
Yes, on a 64-bit OS with Docker. The panel image is published for arm64 as well as amd64.
Why does Minecraft Server Manager need Docker?
Each server runs in its own container, which is how it gets resource limits, a clean rebuild, and the right Java version for every Minecraft version.

Keep Reading

See It With Your Own Server

Install the panel in three steps, then create a server from a modpack in the wizard.